Most financial controllers who move into an FCA-regulated firm from unregulated industry discover compliance monitoring in the same way: an email arrives from the compliance officer saying that client money reconciliations are on the monitoring plan for Q2, and asking for a sample of twelve daily reconciliations with supporting evidence.
The reaction is usually a mix of irritation and mild alarm. Irritation because the request lands in the middle of month-end. Alarm because it is not obvious what “supporting evidence” means, what will be done with it, or what happens if the reviewer does not like what they find.
This guide is written for that moment. It covers what compliance monitoring actually is from the finance side of the table, which finance processes typically appear on a monitoring plan, what a reviewer is looking for, and what it means when a finding is raised against your function. It also covers how to build an evidence file that survives testing, how remediation is tracked to closure, and how all of this connects to the senior managers who answer for compliance under the Senior Managers and Certification Regime.
What monitoring is, and what it is not
Compliance monitoring is a planned, risk-based programme of reviews and tests carried out by the second line — the compliance function — to establish whether the firm actually does what its policies say it does, whether its controls work, and whether customers get good outcomes. It is a requirement rather than a preference: SYSC 6.1 of the FCA Handbook requires firms to maintain adequate policies and procedures to detect any risk of failure to comply with their regulatory obligations, and, where proportionate, a permanent and effective compliance function. For MiFID investment firms, the MiFID Organisational Regulation sets out the monitoring obligation in more detail.
Three distinctions matter to a finance team, because conflating them causes most of the friction.
- Monitoring is not audit. Internal audit is the third line and reports to the audit committee; it assesses whether the whole control framework, including compliance monitoring itself, is adequate. Compliance monitoring is second line and tests the business directly.
- Monitoring is not your own checking. The reconciliation review your finance manager performs before sign-off is first-line quality assurance. It is part of the control being tested, not evidence that testing has happened.
- Monitoring is not advice. The compliance officer who helps you interpret a rule is doing something different from the compliance officer who tests whether you applied it. Good functions keep the two separate, and the reviewer who wrote your procedure should not be the one assessing it.
If the vocabulary of lines is new to you, our companion guide to the three lines of defence for finance teams explains where finance sits and why the distinction matters. SMF Capital’s complete guide to compliance monitoring for FCA-regulated firms sets out how the programme is designed, risk-rated and reported to the board. It is worth reading in full if you are new to a regulated environment, because it explains the machinery your function is about to be assessed by.
From the team
What we see on regulated finance searches
Where finance ends and compliance begins
Finance owns the numbers, controls, reconciliations and regulatory returns. Compliance and the SMF16/17 holders own policy, monitoring, breaches and the relationship with the FCA. Clients most often blur the line on CASS ownership and on who should own the ICARA or the Consumer Duty MI.
The Accountancy Capital team, with Adrian Lawrence FCA overseeing each engagement. View Adrian’s ICAEW profile
Which finance processes land on the plan
Monitoring plans are risk-based, so what appears depends on the firm’s permissions and business model. Across the regulated FC searches we run, these are the finance-owned areas that recur.
| Area | What gets tested | Typical firm types |
|---|---|---|
| Client money and asset reconciliations | Internal and external reconciliations performed daily, differences identified and resolved within the required timeframe, records retained, segregation maintained | Investment managers, brokers, wealth managers, any CASS firm |
| Safeguarding reconciliations | Relevant funds correctly identified and segregated, reconciliation frequency and accuracy, evidence of the safeguarding method applied | Payments and e-money institutions |
| Regulatory returns | Accuracy against the underlying ledger, preparer and reviewer evidence, submission within deadline, resubmission history and why | All authorised firms |
| Prudential and capital monitoring | Own funds and liquidity calculations, headroom monitoring, escalation when thresholds are approached | Investment firms under IFPR, payment institutions |
| Fees, charges and value | Whether charges applied match the published schedule, whether fee structures support the fair value assessment | Retail firms under the Consumer Duty |
| Breach identification and escalation | Whether finance-identified errors reached the breach log, how quickly, and whether any met the notification threshold | All firms |
| Expenses, conflicts and inducements | Approval trails, gifts and hospitality recording, related-party transactions | All firms, higher focus in advice and brokerage |
Two things surprise people. The first is how often regulatory returns appear — finance frequently treats these as a filing exercise and is startled to find the figures traced back to the ledger. The second is that the Consumer Duty has pulled fee and charge data firmly into scope, which means finance data is now tested for customer outcomes rather than just arithmetic. Our note on the management information the Duty requires from finance covers that side in more detail.
The finance areas in more detail
The table gives the headline. In practice, each area has its own evidence trail and its own typical weaknesses, and knowing them in advance is most of the preparation.
CASS and safeguarding reconciliations
For firms holding client money or assets, reconciliations are the single most frequently tested finance control, and the reviewer will usually sample across a period rather than look at the most recent month. They check that each reconciliation was performed on the required day, that internal and external records were compared, that any shortfall was funded promptly, and that breaks were aged and cleared. Our practical guide to CASS reconciliation in practice walks through what a well-evidenced reconciliation looks like.
Payments and e-money firms now face the same scrutiny under CASS 15, the FCA’s strengthened safeguarding regime, which came into force on 7 May 2026 following policy statement PS25/12. It requires safeguarded funds to be reconciled every business day, a new monthly safeguarding return to the FCA, an annual safeguarding audit for most firms, and a resolution pack that would allow funds to be returned promptly on insolvency. Each of those is now a natural monitoring test. Our guide to safeguarding for payments and e-money firms covers the finance side of the new rules.
Regulatory returns via RegData
Returns are submitted through the FCA’s RegData platform, which replaced GABRIEL. A monitoring review of returns typically selects a sample of submissions and traces the key figures back to the trial balance, checks that a reviewer independent of the preparer signed off before submission, confirms deadlines were met, and asks why any return was resubmitted. A resubmission is not a finding in itself; an unexplained one usually is. Our guide to regulatory reporting through RegData sets out the returns finance teams most often own.
Expense and payment controls
Payment approval, supplier set-up and expense claims are tested because they are where conflicts, inducements and fraud risk meet the ledger. Expect the reviewer to check that payments were approved within delegated authority, that bank detail changes were independently verified, that senior staff expenses were approved by someone senior to them, and that gifts and hospitality paid for or received appear in the register. The same evidencing discipline described in our guide to internal controls for growing businesses applies, with the added expectation that the approval trail is retained and retrievable.
Financial promotions, where finance is involved
Financial promotions approval sits with compliance, not finance. But promotions often quote figures that only finance can stand behind: interest rates, fees, performance data, capital strength or customer numbers. Where finance verifies those figures, the reviewer will want to see that the verification happened before sign-off, that the source data was retained, and that the figures were refreshed when they changed. The FCA’s financial promotions guidance requires promotions to be fair, clear and not misleading, and a figure finance cannot evidence fails that test regardless of how good the copy is.
Prudential calculations
For investment firms under the Investment Firms Prudential Regime, own funds, liquidity and K-factor calculations feed both the regulatory returns and the ICARA (Internal Capital Adequacy and Risk Assessment). Payment and e-money firms have their own capital requirements. Monitoring here tests whether the calculation follows the documented methodology, whether headroom against early-warning thresholds is tracked, and whether a breach of an internal trigger was escalated. Our guides to regulatory capital and the ICARA and to showing regulatory capital in management accounts cover the finance mechanics.
Conflicts of interest and personal account dealing
Conflicts management under SYSC 10 and personal account dealing under COBS 11.7 are compliance-owned, but finance is involved in two ways. First, finance holds data that reveals conflicts: related-party payments, intercompany recharges, staff loans and supplier relationships. Second, finance staff themselves often hold inside information, such as unpublished results or capital positions, and so fall within the PA dealing rules where the firm applies them. A reviewer may check that finance staff completed their annual attestations and pre-cleared any relevant trades, and that related-party payments were logged in the conflicts register.
What the reviewer is actually looking for
This is where unregulated habits cause most of the damage, because the standard is different from the one finance usually works to.
In an unregulated business, a reconciliation that is correct is a reconciliation that is finished. In an authorised firm, a reconciliation that is correct but undocumented is a finding. The reviewer is not re-performing your work to see whether you got the right answer; they are establishing whether an independent third party could satisfy themselves, months later, that the work was done properly, by someone competent, at the right time, and that anything unusual was dealt with.
In practice they are testing four things.
- That it happened. Dated, attributable evidence that the control was performed on the required frequency — not a spreadsheet that could have been produced yesterday.
- That someone competent reviewed it. A separate reviewer, evidenced, with enough seniority to challenge. Self-review is the single most common weakness found in small finance teams.
- That exceptions were handled. A reconciliation with no differences every single month is treated as a warning sign, not a success. Reviewers look for breaks being identified, investigated, aged and cleared.
- That the escalation route worked. Where something went wrong, whether it reached the breach log, the compliance officer and — if it crossed the threshold — the regulator.
The uncomfortable implication for a stretched function is that doing the work well is not enough. Our guide to designing financial controls that actually work covers the evidencing discipline that makes a control testable, which in a regulated firm is the difference between a clean review and a finding.
How findings are rated, and what happens next
Findings are normally rated High, Medium or Low, and the rating drives what follows rather than simply recording severity.
| Rating | What it usually means | Consequence for finance |
|---|---|---|
| High | A control is absent or has failed in a way that creates customer harm, regulatory breach or material misstatement risk | Remediation plan with a named owner and a short deadline; board visibility; probable re-test within the quarter; possible FCA notification |
| Medium | The control exists but is inconsistently applied or inadequately evidenced | Agreed action with a date, tracked to closure and re-tested at the next cycle |
| Low | Housekeeping — documentation, version control, minor timing | Logged and tracked; usually closed by the next review |
Three features of the process catch finance teams out. Findings are tracked to closure, so an action accepted and not delivered becomes a worse problem than the original issue. Findings are re-tested, so saying it is fixed is not the same as demonstrating it. And root cause analysis means the reviewer will push past the symptom: a late reconciliation caused by one person’s holiday is a resourcing and succession finding, not a one-off.
That last point is where monitoring and hiring intersect. A recurring finding that traces back to a single person carrying a control with no cover is, in substance, a statement that the function is under-resourced — and it will be read that way by the board.
Finance findings traced back to resourcing? — 0204 553 8893
We provide financial controllers, CASS and regulatory reporting accountants into FCA-authorised firms, permanent, interim and fractional. Interim professionals can usually start within days; we respond the same working day.
Preparing for your first review
If finance has just appeared on the monitoring plan for the first time, five things will make the difference.
- Ask for the scope in writing. Which processes, which period, what sample size, what evidence format, and when the findings will be discussed. A reviewer who cannot answer that has not planned the review properly.
- Walk the process before they do. Follow one transaction end to end and ask whether an outsider could see, from the records alone, that each control operated. The gaps you find yourself are cheaper than the ones they find.
- Fix the evidencing, not the answer. In most first reviews the work is being done correctly and simply is not provable. That is a quick fix and a much better conversation than a control failure.
- Be honest about known issues. A break you have identified, logged and are working through is a functioning control. The same break discovered by the reviewer is a finding.
- Attend the close-out meeting yourself. Findings get drafted in language that will reach the board. If the characterisation is wrong, the time to say so is before it is written up, not afterwards.
Building an evidence file that survives testing
The cheapest way to pass a monitoring review is to make evidence a by-product of doing the work, rather than something assembled when the request arrives. A good evidence file for any finance control contains the same handful of things.
- The procedure it was performed against, with a version number and the date it was last reviewed, so the reviewer can test against the rule that applied at the time.
- The output itself — the reconciliation, the return, the calculation — saved in a locked or read-only form, with the date it was produced visible.
- Preparer and reviewer sign-off, by name and date, ideally captured in the system rather than typed into a cell. An electronic approval trail is far stronger than initials.
- Source data — bank statements, custodian reports, ledger extracts — retained alongside the output so a figure can be re-performed.
- An exceptions log showing what broke, why, who investigated, and when it cleared. This is the part reviewers read most closely.
- Escalation records for anything that went to compliance or the breach log, with the reference number.
Where finance uses automation or AI tools to prepare reconciliations or draft returns, the reviewer will also want to see who checked the output and how. Our guide to human-in-the-loop controls for AI in finance covers what that evidence should look like. A consistent evidence file also makes the regulated month-end close easier to hand over when someone is on leave — which is exactly the single-person risk reviewers look for.
Tracking remediation to closure
Once findings are agreed, they go onto an action log that compliance reports to the board or risk committee, usually monthly or quarterly. Finance should keep its own view of the same log, because the dates you agree in a close-out meeting become the dates you are measured against.
| Log field | What good looks like |
|---|---|
| Finding and rating | The agreed wording and rating from the final report, not a paraphrase |
| Root cause | The underlying cause (process, system, resourcing, training), not the symptom |
| Action and owner | A specific deliverable with one named owner, not “finance team” |
| Target date | Realistic when agreed; any extension requested before the date passes, with reasons |
| Closure evidence | What will prove the fix, agreed with compliance up front so closure is not disputed |
| Re-test result | Compliance’s confirmation that the control now operates, with the date tested |
The common failure is not a missed fix but a missed date. Overdue actions are reported upwards as a separate concern, and a pattern of extensions tells the board more about the function than the original finding did. If a date cannot be met, say so early and explain why.
How monitoring links to SMF16 and SMF17
Under the Senior Managers and Certification Regime, the compliance monitoring programme normally sits under the SMF16 Compliance Oversight function, and financial crime monitoring under the SMF17 Money Laundering Reporting Officer. Those individuals are personally accountable for whether the programme is adequate, which is why they care so much about findings being closed and evidenced. It also explains why a finance function that evidences well tends to be tested less: the SMF16 can rely on it.
The finance-owned control itself remains with whichever senior manager is responsible for finance, often the SMF3 Executive Director or, in larger firms, the SMF2 Chief Finance function. Our guide to the SMCR for finance teams sets out how that accountability is allocated. Note that payments and e-money firms are not in the SM&CR, although they still need an effective compliance function and the same monitoring discipline.
For senior finance managers thinking about moving into a compliance oversight role, our note on moving from senior finance manager to SMF16/17 covers what to ask. Firms appointing an SMF16 or SMF17 can work with our sister firm SMF Capital, which specialises in senior manager function appointments, while SMF2 holders and Finance Directors are provided by FD Capital.
What this means for hiring
There is a meaningful difference between a financial controller who has produced a regulatory return and one who has had their return tested, challenged and re-performed by a second line reviewer. The second has learned a discipline the first has not: that in a regulated firm, the work is not finished when the number is right, it is finished when the number is demonstrable.
It is also the reason that the regulated premium exists. Candidates who have operated inside an authorised firm and been through monitoring cycles are genuinely scarcer than the job adverts suggest, which is the subject of our note on why regulated-firm finance roles pay a premium. When we run FC searches for FCA-regulated firms, the interview question that separates candidates fastest is simply: tell me about a monitoring finding raised against your function, and what changed afterwards.
Candidates who have lived it describe the finding, the root cause and the re-test. Candidates who have not describe their policies.
The short version
Compliance monitoring is not an audit, not an attack and not optional. It is the firm’s own mechanism for finding problems before the regulator does, and finance is squarely within its scope — client money, safeguarding, returns, capital, fees and breach escalation all sit on the plan at most authorised firms.
For a well-run function the review is an inconvenience and a validation. For a function where the work is sound but the evidence is thin, it is a wake-up call that is far better delivered internally than by a supervisor. And for a function carrying controls on one person’s shoulders, it is the document that finally makes the resourcing gap visible to the board.
If you are new to the regulated environment and want to understand the programme that is about to assess you, SMF Capital’s guide to compliance monitoring explains how the plan is built, risk-rated, tested and reported.
Where Finance Ends and Compliance Begins
The distinction that works in practice is between producing information and deciding what it means.
Finance produces: the numbers, the reconciliations, the data behind the returns, the underlying records. Compliance decides: whether the firm’s position meets its obligations, whether something requires notification, whether a pattern warrants escalation, and whether the controls around all of it are adequate.
Where that split is written down and agreed, the firm runs smoothly. Where it is not, both functions assume the other has it.
Three items are worth agreeing explicitly: who signs off a regulatory return and on what basis; what finance does when a reconciliation breaks; and what triggers an escalation from finance to the MLRO, in concrete terms rather than as a general principle.
Consumer Duty MI: The Pieces Finance Owns
Price and value assessment. This is the outcome most dependent on finance. Demonstrating that a product provides fair value requires the cost of providing it, the revenue earned from it, the margin by product and by customer segment, and the distribution of that margin across the customer base. Firms that have never costed products at that granularity discover the gap quickly — and it is a management accounting problem before it is a compliance one.
Charges and fee data. What customers actually paid, including any variation between segments or channels, and whether identical customers received materially different outcomes on price.
Distribution economics. Where intermediaries or partners are involved, the total cost to the customer across the chain — which requires visibility finance often has and the business often does not.
Remediation and redress costs. Where outcomes were poor, what it cost to put right — both a compliance data point and a P&L one, and a useful leading indicator of where the problems are.
Foregone revenue. Less obvious and increasingly asked for: where the firm chose not to charge, waived a fee or exited a product on fair-value grounds, that is evidence of the Duty operating and it shows up in finance’s numbers rather than anywhere else.
What a usable price and value analysis contains
The FCA’s published good and poor practice — for example its review of fair value in consumer finance — repeatedly comes back to the same weakness: assessments that assert value rather than measure it. In practice, a price and value analysis that will stand up to challenge usually includes:
- Total price paid per customer, built from every charge, fee, interest element and ancillary cost, not only the headline price.
- Revenue, direct cost, allocated cost and margin for each product, and for each material customer segment within the product.
- The distribution of outcomes — for example the spread of total cost or margin across customers — so that outliers and cross-subsidies are visible.
- Comparison points: similar products, back-book versus front-book pricing, market comparators.
- The non-financial benefits the product delivers, sourced from product and customer teams, so price is set against benefit rather than against cost alone.
Finance cannot produce the last item alone, but should own the structure. The pricing logic is close to ordinary commercial pricing work — our guide to how management accountants support pricing decisions covers the underlying discipline.
What SM&CR Means for Each Finance Role
| Role | Typical SM&CR position |
|---|---|
| CFO / FD | SMF2 at an enhanced firm; usually SMF3 at a core firm if on the board; otherwise certified. Personally accountable under the duty of responsibility if an SMF. |
| Head of Finance / Financial Controller | Often certified (significant management or manager of certified staff), especially at core firms. May hold delegated responsibility for regulatory reporting, capital or CASS. |
| Finance Manager / Regulatory Reporting Manager | Sometimes certified where they manage certified staff; always subject to the Conduct Rules. |
| Management, financial and CASS accountants | Usually not certified; subject to the Conduct Rules, with breaches reportable and recorded on regulatory references. |
The position at any given firm depends on its tier and how it has drawn its Statements of Responsibilities and certification functions, so ask. A good employer will tell you at offer stage whether a role is certified. For more on how regulated finance roles differ from commercial ones, see regulated vs commercial Financial Controller, and for pay, our regulated-firm finance salary guide.
When Finance and Compliance Report Different Numbers: A First Pass
Pick the three numbers that appear in both the compliance report and the management accounts. In most firms they are redress or remediation paid, complaint-related costs, and fees or charges by customer segment.
For each one, ask four questions. What event causes a transaction to be counted? Which entities are in scope? Is the figure gross or net? What is the cut-off? Then run both figures for the same period and compare.
In our experience of regulated finance functions, the first comparison often produces a variance, and the variance is almost always explicable once the definitions are written down. The value is not in the number. It is in discovering that two functions had been using the same word to mean different things, before someone external asks which one the board relied on.
Frequently asked questions
How often will finance be monitored?
It depends on the risk assessment behind the plan. High-risk areas such as client money or safeguarding reconciliations may be tested every quarter or half-year; lower-risk areas perhaps every year or two. A finding usually brings a re-test sooner than the normal cycle.
Is a monitoring finding reported to the FCA?
Not automatically. Findings go to senior management and the board. Notification to the FCA follows only where the underlying issue meets a notification requirement in the Handbook, such as a significant breach. That judgement belongs to compliance, which is why finance should raise issues early rather than wait for the review.
Can we disagree with a finding?
Yes, and you should if the facts are wrong. The place to do it is the close-out meeting or the draft report stage, with evidence. Disagreeing with the rating is reasonable; disagreeing because the fix is inconvenient is not, and tends to be noticed.
What if our firm has no separate compliance function?
Smaller firms often outsource monitoring to a compliance consultancy, or combine it with a part-time compliance officer. The rules allow proportionality, but the monitoring still needs to be independent of the people doing the work. A finance director testing their own team’s reconciliations does not count.
Do payments and e-money firms face the same monitoring?
They are outside the SM&CR but not outside monitoring. With CASS 15 now in force, safeguarding reconciliations, the monthly safeguarding return and the resolution pack are obvious candidates for the plan, and the annual safeguarding audit adds an external check on top.
What experience should we look for when hiring a controller for a regulated firm?
Someone who has been through monitoring cycles, can describe a finding and its fix, and understands why evidence matters as much as accuracy. Our guide to interviewing for regulated-firm finance roles covers the questions that test this.
Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, Accountancy Capital
Fellow of the ICAEW | Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate | Part of FD Capital Group
Adrian is a former listed-company Finance Director and holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London. He founded FD Capital in 2018 and later Accountancy Capital, where our recruitment team places qualified finance professionals into FCA-authorised firms that need controllers able to stand behind their evidence as well as their numbers.
Related Pages and Resources
FC recruitment for FCA-regulated firms
Controllers who have operated inside authorised firms and been through monitoring cycles.
CASS and safeguarding
Client money and safeguarding specialists for investment and payments firms.
Regulatory reporting
People who can produce returns that survive being tested.
FCA finance guides
Our library for finance teams in authorised firms.
Hiring finance into an FCA-regulated firm? — 0204 553 8893
Interim and fractional professionals can usually start within days, on one all-inclusive day rate. Call us or email recruitment@accountancycapital.co.uk and we will respond the same working day.
Adrian Lawrence FCA is the founder of Accountancy Capital and FD Capital Group. He is a Fellow of the ICAEW with a practising certificate and a former listed-company Finance Director, with more than 25 years at C-suite level, including Finance Director roles in private equity-backed businesses. He holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London. Adrian founded the group to give growing businesses access to experienced finance professionals, on an interim, fractional or permanent basis, and oversees every engagement the team runs.