Managing the Year-End Audit Relationship

How a Financial Controller manages the relationship with the audit firm: the planning meeting, communication cadence, the audit committee, disagreements on judgements, management letter points, fees and overruns, tendering, and the revised ISA (UK) 240 and 570.

  • Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW
  • Permanent, interim and fractional finance hires
  • Offices in London and the West Midlands
Financial controller reviewing figures

The relationship between a Financial Controller and the external auditor is one of the more important professional relationships in the role, and one that is often mismanaged in both directions. Treated as a contest in which the finance function withholds and the auditor probes, it produces a slow, expensive audit and a poor outcome for everyone. Treated as a professional relationship built on openness, competence and clear expectations, it produces a smoother audit, fewer fee disputes and an auditor whose observations are genuinely useful.

This guide covers the relationship itself, not the year-end checklist. For the timeline, PBC list, reconciliations and judgement papers, see our companion guide to Financial Controller audit preparation; for the hands-on tasks that sit with the team, see the Financial Accountant’s role in the audit. Here we deal with the planning meeting, how often to talk and to whom, working with the audit committee, handling disagreements on judgements, management letter points, fee discussions and overruns, rotation and tendering, and the revised auditing standards on fraud and going concern.

Understanding the Auditor’s Position

A good working relationship starts with understanding the auditor’s role and constraints. Their job is to form an independent opinion on the financial statements, and their professional standing depends on doing it properly. They must be independent, exercise professional scepticism and gather enough evidence to support the opinion, so they will probe and will not simply accept management’s word. That is not personal distrust; it is the job.

Auditors also work under pressure of their own: deadlines, stretched staff, and inspection by the Financial Reporting Council and the professional bodies, which has raised the rigour expected on every file. When an audit senior pushes hard on an area, they are usually responding to the standards and to what their reviewers will ask, not being deliberately difficult. A Financial Controller who understands this can engage with the auditor as a fellow professional rather than an adversary.

The Planning Meeting: Setting the Terms

Most of the friction in an audit can be traced back to things that were not agreed at planning. Ask for a planning meeting three to four months before the year end with the audit manager and, ideally, the engagement partner, and go in with your own agenda rather than just receiving theirs. Points worth agreeing and recording:

  • Timetable — interim and final fieldwork dates, the date for draft accounts, the clearance meeting and the signing date, working back from the board or audit committee meeting.
  • Team and continuity — who the senior and manager will be, whether they worked on last year’s audit, and how much of the fieldwork is on site.
  • Risks and materiality — the significant risks the firm has identified and the approach to materiality, so you know where the effort will go.
  • Business changes — acquisitions, new financing, restructuring, new systems and new contract types. Tell the auditor now, not in fieldwork.
  • Accounting changes — for periods beginning on or after 1 January 2026, the FRS 102 changes to leases and revenue. Agree the approach and the evidence expected early; our guides to lease accounting and revenue recognition explain the underlying models.
  • The PBC list — every item with an owner and a date, and the format the auditor wants.
  • Fees and what drives them — the fee estimate, what it assumes about your readiness, and how out-of-scope work will be flagged and agreed.
  • Use of technology — data extraction, data analytics, and how the auditor will look at any AI tools the finance team uses. What auditors ask about AI covers the questions to expect.

Follow up with a short written summary of what was agreed. If a dispute arises later over timing or fees, a note sent within a day of planning is far more useful than recollection.

Communication Throughout the Audit

Good communication is the practical heart of the relationship, and it should run on a cadence rather than happen when something goes wrong. A pattern that works for most mid-sized audits:

Stage Who Cadence and purpose
Between audits FC and audit manager Quarterly or as needed: significant transactions, accounting questions before they become audit issues
Planning FC, FD/CFO, manager, partner One meeting plus written summary: timetable, risks, scope, fees
Fieldwork FC or Financial Accountant and audit senior Daily short catch-up on the request tracker; issues raised the day they are found
Fieldwork FC and audit manager Weekly status: open items, emerging adjustments, judgement points, fee risk
Clearance FC, FD/CFO, partner Adjustments, unadjusted differences, management letter, representation letter
After signing FC and manager Debrief: what slowed the audit on both sides, and changes for next year

The principle underneath is no surprises in either direction. The Financial Controller should not be surprised by findings at clearance, because issues were surfaced as they arose, and the auditor should not be surprised by the finance function, because problems and judgements were disclosed openly. Most audit difficulties trace back to a failure here. One practical rule: keep a single channel for requests (one shared tracker, one named contact on each side) so nothing is lost across emails to different team members. If the team uses AI tools to draft schedules or responses, agree with the auditor how that work is reviewed and evidenced; AI for audit preparation covers the practical side.

The Audit Committee and Governance Dimension

In larger businesses, particularly listed, PE-backed and regulated ones, the auditor relationship runs through the audit committee. The committee oversees the external auditor, the integrity of financial reporting and the effectiveness of controls, and the auditor reports to it as well as to management. For listed companies, the UK Corporate Governance Code sets out the committee’s role, including recommending the appointment of the auditor and assessing its independence and effectiveness.

For the Financial Controller, that means a few things in practice. The committee will usually meet the auditor without management present, and you should expect and welcome that. Significant judgement papers — going concern, impairment, revenue — should go to the committee before the auditor’s report on them, so members see management’s reasoning first. The audit plan, the auditor’s findings and the management letter will be tabled, so your responses need to be ready and agreed beforehand. Committee papers follow the same principles as board papers; our guide to board pack preparation covers the format. Where a committee lacks financial expertise, an independent chair with recent finance experience makes a real difference, and our sister firm NED Capital handles non-executive and audit committee chair appointments.

Owner-managed businesses without a committee still benefit from the discipline: a short pre-clearance session with the directors, with the key judgements and the proposed adjustments on one page, does much the same job.

Handling Disagreements on Judgements

Every audit has moments of tension: a challenge to a provision, a different view of when revenue should be recognised, an impairment the auditor thinks is needed. The instinct to dig in is understandable but counterproductive. A structured approach works better:

  • Raise it early. A judgement flagged at planning is a discussion; the same judgement found in final fieldwork is a dispute.
  • Put the position in writing. A short paper setting out facts, the requirement in the standard, the options considered and the conclusion moves the discussion onto the merits.
  • Understand their concern. Ask what evidence would satisfy them. Often the disagreement is about support rather than the answer.
  • Escalate in an orderly way. Senior to manager to partner, and if needed the firm’s technical team. On your side, bring in the FD or CFO and, for material points, the audit committee chair.
  • Accept when they are right. Sometimes the auditor has spotted something the team missed. Conceding gracefully preserves credibility for the points that matter.

Know how the endgame works. Misstatements the auditor identifies are either adjusted or listed as unadjusted differences; the directors confirm in the letter of representation that unadjusted items are immaterial, individually and in aggregate. If a material disagreement cannot be resolved, the auditor may modify the opinion, which no business wants and which is almost always avoidable through earlier, better-documented discussion. Never sign a representation letter you are not comfortable with: it is a statement by the directors, and the Financial Controller usually drafts the evidence behind it.

Management Letter Points

The management letter (sometimes called the letter of recommendations or report to those charged with governance) sets out control weaknesses and other matters found during the audit. Handle it as a working document, not a verdict:

  • Ask to see points in draft and check facts before they go to the board. Factual errors are common and easy to correct at draft stage.
  • Give each point a management response with an owner and a date. Vague responses (“management will consider”) invite the same point next year.
  • Push back on priority where justified. A low-risk process point rated high distracts the board from real issues.
  • Track actions through the year and report progress to the committee or board before the next planning meeting.

A management letter that shrinks year on year is one of the clearest signals of a finance function improving, and repeated points are what an incoming FD or acquirer will notice first. Many points relate to segregation of duties, journal authorisation and reconciliation review; our guide to designing financial controls that actually work covers the fixes.

Need a Financial Controller who can run the audit? — 0204 553 8893

Accountancy Capital places permanent, interim and fractional Financial Controllers across the UK. We respond the same working day; permanent shortlists are typically within one to two weeks and interim within days.

Tell us about your hire →Register as a candidate →

Fee Discussions and Overruns

Audit fees have risen across the market as standards and inspection have tightened, and overrun charges have become a common source of friction. The fee estimate in the engagement letter is built on assumptions about your readiness: when draft accounts arrive, how complete the PBC pack is, and how many adjustments are expected. When those assumptions fail, firms bill for the extra time.

Typical causes of overruns are late or incomplete PBC items, draft accounts that change materially during fieldwork, unreconciled balances, new transactions not flagged at planning, judgement papers that do not exist, and turnover in either team. Some causes sit with the audit firm: inexperienced staff, review points raised late, or work repeated because of their own internal changes.

To manage it, agree in writing at planning how out-of-scope work will be identified, and ask for overruns to be flagged as they arise, not presented on the final invoice. Track readiness against the PBC list (our audit preparation checklist includes a typical one) so you can show where delays were yours and where they were not. When an overrun is presented, ask for a breakdown by area and cause, and be willing to accept the part that reflects your own late delivery. The best lever on next year’s fee is a cleaner audit this year: firms price risk and hours, and a finance function that delivers what it promised, on time, is cheaper to audit.

Auditor Rotation and Tendering

For public interest entities — broadly UK companies with securities traded on a regulated market, banks, building societies and insurers — the rules are prescriptive. The audit must be put out to tender at least once a decade, and the same firm can generally serve for no more than 20 years in total, after which it must step aside for a cooling-off period. Within the firm, the engagement partner on a PIE audit must normally rotate after five years under the FRC’s Ethical Standard. Smaller listed companies and some PIEs have limited exemptions. ICAEW’s audit tenders guidance covers the detail.

For private companies there is no mandatory rotation, though investors, lenders and acquirers may push for a change, and PE houses often move portfolio companies to a preferred firm. Whether mandatory or voluntary, a tender typically runs through a long list, a request for proposal with access to management and data, presentations, and a recommendation from the audit committee or board. The Financial Controller usually builds the data room and fields the firms’ questions. Assess the proposed team, sector experience and approach to your key judgements as much as the fee. Our guide to the cooling-off periods for audit work is relevant if you are hiring someone from the outgoing firm.

A first-year audit with a new firm is more expensive and slower for both sides, because the new auditor must get comfortable with opening balances and your processes. Budget for that, and plan the handover of prior-year working papers between firms early. In PE-backed groups the timing of a change often follows the deal; see Financial Controllers for PE-backed companies.

Revised ISA (UK) 240 and 570: What Changes for Management

In March 2026 the FRC issued revised versions of ISA (UK) 240 (the auditor’s responsibilities relating to fraud) and ISA (UK) 570 (going concern), following the international standard-setter’s revisions. They apply to audits of financial statements for periods beginning on or after 15 December 2026, so for most companies the first audits affected are December 2027 year-ends. The FRC’s announcement notes that UK standards had already been strengthened, so it expects limited extra work, but management should still expect:

  • Fraud — more rigorous fraud risk assessment, more questions to management and those charged with governance about fraud risks and known or suspected fraud, and continued focus on journals and management override. For listed and other publicly traded entities, more transparency in the auditor’s report about fraud-related matters.
  • Going concern — a stronger evaluation of management’s assessment, including challenge of the forecasts, assumptions and mitigating actions, and clearer reporting on the auditor’s conclusions.

In practice, the Financial Controller should make sure the fraud risk assessment is documented (not just discussed), that journal controls and authorisation are evidenced, and that the going concern paper sets out scenarios and the basis for each key assumption. Raise both at the planning meeting for the first affected year so there are no late requests.

When the Relationship Is Under Strain

Not every auditor relationship is easy. A fundamental disagreement on a material judgement, an audit team that seems unreasonable, or a year in which significant problems are found will all test it. Professionalism matters most: keep to the substance, escalate within both organisations where working-level discussion has stalled, and focus on the right answer rather than winning the argument.

Where the strain is persistent — the relationship with a partner has broken down, or the audit consistently fails to serve the business — changing auditor may come up. That is a decision for the board or audit committee, with costs of its own, and in most cases the better path is to reset the relationship through a frank partner-level conversation and a clear plan for next year.

Getting Value Beyond the Audit Opinion

Auditors see many businesses and understand accounting and controls deeply, so a well-managed relationship gives more than an opinion: a view on emerging requirements, on how your controls compare, and on difficult accounting questions before they become audit issues. Independence rules limit what the audit firm can do for you beyond the audit, especially for PIEs, but asking their view on a technical question is part of the relationship. Take the observations seriously, act on them, and treat the audit as an expert external review of the finance function. Over several cycles, a relationship built on openness and delivery produces progressively smoother audits.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who should own the relationship with the audit firm?

Day to day, the Financial Controller. The FD or CFO owns the partner relationship and material judgements, and the audit committee, where there is one, oversees the auditor’s appointment and independence. Where the business has no FD, the Financial Controller often covers both; senior finance leadership is the work of our sister firm FD Capital.

How do we challenge an audit overrun fee?

Ask for a breakdown by area and cause, compare it against what was agreed at planning and the PBC tracker, and accept the share caused by your own late or incomplete delivery. Agreeing in advance that overruns are flagged as they arise prevents most disputes.

Do private companies have to rotate auditors?

No. Mandatory tendering and rotation apply to public interest entities. Private companies can keep the same firm indefinitely, although partner rotation rules still apply within the firm and investors may push for a tender.

When do the revised ISA (UK) 240 and 570 apply?

To audits of periods beginning on or after 15 December 2026. For a calendar-year company, the first affected audit is the year ending 31 December 2027.

What if the audit is late because we have no Financial Controller?

An interim Financial Controller can take over the relationship and the close at short notice; London day rates are typically £400–£650. See interim Financial Controller for audit preparation, or our Financial Controller recruitment page for permanent hires.

Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, Accountancy Capital

Fellow of the ICAEW | Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate | Part of FD Capital Group

Adrian is a Fellow of the ICAEW with a practising certificate and a former listed-company Finance Director. He holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London, founded FD Capital in 2018 and later Accountancy Capital, which recruits Financial Controllers and qualified finance professionals below director level across the UK.

View Adrian’s ICAEW profile

Related Pages and Resources

Hiring a Financial Controller Who Manages the Audit Well? — 0204 553 8893

Accountancy Capital places qualified Financial Controllers across the UK on permanent, interim and fractional terms — people who build professional auditor relationships and run year-ends that conclude on time. Email recruitment@accountancycapital.co.uk or tell us about the role and our recruitment team will respond the same working day. Fees are agreed in writing before a search starts.

Tell us about your hire →Register as a candidate →

Start a search

Tell us about your finance hire

Share a few details about the role and your timetable. A consultant will review your brief and come back to you the same working day.

  • Same-day response from a consultant who works on finance searches every day
  • Confidential from the first conversation, with no obligation to proceed
  • Permanent, interim and fractional finance roles across the UK
Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Your details are used only to respond to your enquiry.