Most FCA-regulated businesses hire their first dedicated Financial Controller at the point where the absence of one has already caused a problem. The CASS reconciliation has failed an internal review. A RegData return was submitted late. The FCA has sent a Dear CEO letter that the compliance team cannot fully answer without financial data the finance function cannot readily produce. The reactive hire is more expensive, more urgent and riskier than the proactive one — and the signs that warrant a proactive hire are usually visible well before the crisis.
This piece describes five specific signals that an FCA-regulated business needs a Financial Controller with specialist regulatory finance experience — rather than a competent general FC who will learn the regulatory environment on the job. It is written for founders, CEOs, finance directors and boards of authorised firms, and it sits alongside our guide to what the FCA expects from your finance function, which sets out the supervisory expectations each sign relates to.
1. Your CASS Reconciliation Is Managed by Compliance Rather Than Finance
CASS client money reconciliations are a finance function responsibility in a correctly structured regulated firm. The daily internal client money reconciliation, the custody reconciliation and the periodic external reconciliation are financial processes that require the financial rigour, auditability and control framework of the finance team — not the resource or skill set of the compliance team. Compliance should oversee and challenge the process; finance should run it.
Where the compliance team is managing the CASS reconciliation because the finance team lacks the regulatory knowledge to own it, the firm has a structural vulnerability. Client money failings have featured in some of the FCA’s most significant enforcement cases, and the firms that suffer the worst consequences from CASS breaches are typically those where the reconciliation was managed informally rather than within a proper financial control framework. The FCA’s client money and assets pages set out its supervisory focus.
The same applies to payment and e-money institutions, whose safeguarding has run under the FCA’s CASS 15 rules since 7 May 2026, with daily reconciliations, a monthly safeguarding return and an annual audit. If safeguarding sits with an operations or compliance colleague rather than finance, this sign applies to you too — see our guide to safeguarding for payments and e-money firms.
An FC with CASS experience will own the reconciliation process, build a control framework around it that satisfies both the CASS auditor and FCA supervision, and produce the reconciliation documentation to the standard the FCA expects. See CASS Accountant Recruitment and FC at FCA-Regulated Firms for the candidate profile, and CASS reconciliation in practice for what good looks like.
2. Your GABRIEL (Now RegData) Returns Are Prepared by Someone Who Is Not Sure What They Mean
GABRIEL was the FCA’s online regulatory reporting system; it has been replaced by RegData, through which every firm now submits its data items. The returns — the MIFIDPRU own funds and liquidity returns (MIF001 and MIF002) and the annual ICARA questionnaire (MIF007) for investment firms, the RMAR for insurance intermediaries, the CMAR for CASS medium and large firms, and the safeguarding return for payments and e-money firms — are a primary data source the FCA uses to monitor the financial health and regulatory compliance of the firms it supervises. Errors are noticed, and supervisors compare a firm’s submissions with what they would expect to see from its business model and its published accounts.
The FC at a regulated firm who understands what each return is measuring, why the FCA collects that data, and what a material discrepancy in a return will trigger in terms of supervisory attention is managing a significant regulatory risk on behalf of the firm. The finance professional who is filling in the forms because someone has to, without that understanding, is producing regulatory submissions that may be technically completed but are not being managed as the risk management tool they represent. Our guides to RegData, COREP and FINREP and regulatory capital, the ICARA and IFPR set out the returns in more detail.
3. Your Finance Team Cannot Produce a Consumer Duty Price and Value Assessment
Since 31 July 2023 for open products (and 31 July 2024 for closed books), FCA-regulated firms serving retail customers have been required to demonstrate that the price consumers pay for their products and services represents fair value relative to the benefits received. The price and value assessment requires product-level margin analysis, distribution cost analysis and a documented assessment of value — all of which are finance function outputs.
The regulated firm whose finance team cannot produce a credible price and value assessment without significant external support is carrying a Consumer Duty compliance gap that the FCA’s outcomes-focused supervision is designed to find. The FCA Consumer Duty framework is now more than three years into its operational phase and the FCA has moved firmly from implementation review to testing outcomes. The regime has been simplified at the edges — the expectation of a board Consumer Duty champion was dropped in February 2025, and the CP26/23 consultation closed on 18 September 2026 — but none of that removes the need for fair value evidence. A specialist FC who has built price and value assessment capabilities at a previous regulated employer is often the most efficient route to closing this gap. Our guide to the Consumer Duty MI finance must produce lists the outputs.
4. Your Last FCA Visit Produced Management Letter Points About Financial Controls
FCA supervisory work and thematic reviews regularly produce findings about the quality of financial controls at regulated firms. Recurring themes include CASS reconciliation weakness, inadequate wind-down planning and financial resource calculations, poor management information about the regulatory capital position, and insufficient documentation of the firm’s ICARA (Internal Capital Adequacy and Risk Assessment). The same points often arrive from the external auditor or the CASS auditor first.
Each of these findings is a finance function responsibility. Where the FCA is raising them, it is usually because the finance function has not owned them adequately. A specialist FC who has been through FCA supervisory contact — either as the FC of the firm concerned or as a member of the team preparing the response — understands what the FCA is looking for and can build the control and documentation framework that prevents the same findings recurring.
See Investment Firm FC, Insurance Intermediary FC and FCA Finance Recruitment Hub for the regulatory finance candidate profiles we work with.
5. Your Finance Director or CFO Is Spending Significant Time on Regulatory Finance
The Finance Director or CFO of an FCA-regulated business should be operating at the strategic financial level — the capital structure, the board relationship, the investor reporting, the commercial finance partnership with the business. Where the FD or CFO is spending material time on CASS reconciliations, RegData submissions, regulatory capital calculations or ICARA documentation, the firm does not have the right finance team structure. At an enhanced firm under the Senior Managers and Certification Regime, where the CFO may hold the SMF2 Chief Finance function, that time is also time not spent on the accountability the regulator expects them to discharge.
This is typically the clearest and most actionable signal that a specialist FC hire is overdue. The FD’s time is the most expensive time in the finance function. When it is being consumed by operational regulatory finance work that an experienced FC should own, much of the cost of the specialist FC hire is offset by the FD’s time released alone — before accounting for the improvement in regulatory finance quality that a specialist FC brings.
The return on the hire comes through a combination of FD time released, regulatory risk reduced and finance function quality improved. Call 0204 553 8893 to discuss whether your firm is at the point where a specialist FC hire makes sense, or see FC at FCA-Regulated Firms and Wealth Management FC.
Specialist FC Recruitment for FCA-Regulated Firms — 0204 553 8893
Accountancy Capital places Financial Controllers with CASS, safeguarding, RegData, Consumer Duty and SMCR experience at FCA-regulated businesses. Same working day response; permanent shortlists typically within one to two weeks, interim and fractional within days.
When Two or More Signs Appear Together
The five signs above are individually significant. Where a firm is showing two or more simultaneously, the case for a specialist FC hire is usually clear and often urgent. The regulatory finance risk carried by an FCA-regulated business without an FC who owns the CASS or safeguarding framework, the RegData submissions, the Consumer Duty data and the capital adequacy calculation is a risk that FCA supervision is increasingly likely to surface.
The cost of a specialist regulated firm FC — typically £75,000 to £110,000 in London at an asset manager or investment firm, and £65,000 to £95,000 at a fintech or payments firm, depending on the size and complexity of the firm — should be assessed against the cost of the regulatory risk it manages: FCA enforcement action, a section 166 skilled persons review, voluntary requirements, and the reputational and commercial impact of a public regulatory finding. Regulated experience typically commands a premium of 15–25% over an equivalent commercial FC. See FC Salary Guide UK, our regulated-firm finance salary guide, Asset Management FC and Investment Firm FC for the full regulated firm FC recruitment picture.
The Interim and Fractional Option
One dimension worth adding to this picture is the interim or fractional option. Where an FCA-regulated business is showing the signs above but is not yet at the scale to justify a permanent specialist FC hire — or where the need is urgent and a permanent candidate may be serving up to three months’ notice — an interim regulated firm FC can provide immediate cover while the permanent solution is developed. Interim regulated FCs typically charge £440–£600 a day, and we can usually present candidates within days.
The interim option is particularly relevant for firms that have received a management letter point from the FCA or their external auditors about regulatory finance quality. The urgency of that situation typically cannot wait for a permanent hire, and an experienced interim FC who has handled FCA supervisory contact before can stabilise the position while the firm conducts a considered permanent search. For smaller firms, a fractional FC one or two days a week is often the permanent answer — see fractional FC for FCA-regulated firms, Interim Finance Recruitment, Maternity Cover FC and the cryptoasset-specific guide to finance in a cryptoasset firm for firms preparing for the FCA’s new regime, whose application gateway opened on 30 September 2026 and closes on 28 February 2027 ahead of the regime starting on 25 October 2027.
Specialist FC or General FC: What the Difference Looks Like
| Area | General FC learning on the job | Specialist regulated FC |
|---|---|---|
| Client money / safeguarding | Follows the existing reconciliation template | Knows which CASS regime applies, owns the controls and the resolution pack |
| Regulatory returns | Completes RegData items from the ledger | Reconciles returns to the accounts and explains movements before the FCA asks |
| Capital | Updates the capital calculation annually | Monitors headroom monthly and reports it in the management accounts |
| Consumer Duty | Provides data when compliance asks | Builds product-level margin and value MI as a standing output |
| Supervisory contact | First experience of FCA questions | Has answered data requests and audit points before |
Our comparison of the regulated and commercial Financial Controller and our note on the skills a regulated-sector FC needs go further.
How to Brief the Search
- Name the regime. CASS 5, CASS 7, CASS 15 safeguarding, MIFIDPRU or MIPRU — experience is not interchangeable.
- Check the firm was authorised. Many fintech CVs come from agents of a principal firm that never held relevant funds.
- Prioritise. Decide which one or two of the five signs matter most; asking for every capability at manager level narrows the pool to almost nothing.
- Separate approved roles. If the role carries SMF2 at an enhanced firm, the search runs with our sister firm FD Capital; SMF16 and SMF17 appointments run with SMF Capital.
- Time it against the calendar. Avoid hiring in the fortnight before a CASS audit or a return deadline if you can; bring in interim cover if you cannot.
The FCA’s SMCR pages explain which roles are senior manager functions, and our regulated finance hiring market report covers current scarcity and pay across the disciplines.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a specialist FC at an FCA-regulated firm?
A qualified Financial Controller who has already worked inside an authorised firm and owned its regulatory finance: client money or safeguarding reconciliations, RegData returns, the capital calculation and Consumer Duty value MI.
How much does a specialist regulated FC cost?
In London, typically £75k–£110k at an asset manager or investment firm and £65k–£95k at a fintech or payments firm. Interim regulated FCs typically charge £440–£600 a day.
Can a general FC learn the regulatory side?
Yes, given time and support, and for a low-risk firm that can be the right choice. Where client money, capital headroom or a recent finding is in play, the learning period is a risk the firm carries.
Does the FC need to be an approved person?
Usually not. SMF2 applies only at enhanced firms and is normally held by the CFO or FD; the FC is more often a certified or conduct-rules employee.
How quickly can you find one?
We respond the same working day. Permanent shortlists typically follow within one to two weeks, and interim or fractional candidates within days.
Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, Accountancy Capital
Fellow of the ICAEW | Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate | Part of FD Capital Group
Adrian is a former listed-company Finance Director with a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London. He regards the regulated firm FC brief as one of the most technically specific searches the team runs, because general FC capability combined with real regulatory finance knowledge is genuinely rare. If your firm is showing any of the five signs, talk to a specialist recruiter who knows that candidate market — see our Knowledge Centre for more.
Related Pages and Resources
Regulated FC Recruitment
Controllers for authorised firms.
FCA Expectations
What supervision asks of finance.
Sector FCs
Profiles by type of regulated firm.
Hire a specialist regulated FC — 0204 553 8893
Call, or email recruitment@accountancycapital.co.uk. Offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Watling Street, Cannock WS11 0EL. Fees are agreed in writing before a search starts.
Related posts:
Adrian Lawrence FCA is the founder of Accountancy Capital and a Fellow of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales (ICAEW). He holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London, and has over 25 years of experience as a Chartered Accountant and finance leader working with private, PE-backed and owner-managed businesses across the UK
He helps his clients achieve their growth and success goals by delivering value and results in areas such as Financial Modelling, Finance Raising, M&A, Due Diligence, cash flow management, and reporting. He is passionate about supporting SMEs and entrepreneurs with reliable and professional Chief Financial Officer or Finance Director services.