A Financial Controller’s Guide to R&D Tax Claims

A practical guide for Financial Controllers on UK R&D tax relief: the merged scheme and ERIS, claim notification, the additional information form, cost capture, documentation and how to prepare a claim that stands up to HMRC scrutiny.

  • Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW
  • Permanent, interim and fractional finance hires
  • Offices in London and the West Midlands
Tax professionals in a meeting

Research and Development tax relief is one of the most valuable government incentives available to UK companies, and one of the areas where a Financial Controller can add direct, measurable value. A well-prepared claim returns real cash or a meaningful reduction in the corporation tax charge; a poorly prepared one either leaves money on the table or, increasingly, invites an HMRC enquiry that costs far more in time and risk than the relief is worth.

This guide is written for Financial Controllers and senior finance professionals who are responsible for, or contribute to, their company’s R&D claim. It is not a substitute for specialist advice on a complex claim. It sets out what qualifies, how the current schemes work, the deadlines and forms that now apply, how to quantify eligible costs and how to prepare a claim that withstands a considerably tougher HMRC environment.

Why R&D Relief Matters to the Financial Controller

The Financial Controller is unusually well placed in the R&D claim process. Technical teams understand the projects but rarely the tax rules or the cost identification; the external adviser understands the rules but has no day-to-day visibility of the projects or the cost base; and the company’s tax position, payroll data and cost ledgers all sit within finance. The Financial Controller is the person who connects the technical narrative to the financial substantiation, and the quality of that connection largely determines the quality of the claim.

This matters more than ever because the regime has changed substantially. HMRC has sharply increased its scrutiny of claims after a period of widespread error and abuse in the old SME scheme, and the rules have been reformed with the merger of the two historic schemes. A Financial Controller who treats the claim as a once-a-year exercise handed wholesale to an adviser is exposing the company to risk. One who understands the substance can make sure the claim is both maximised and defensible. Where a business also uses the Patent Box or is weighing an in-house tax hire, our guide to building R&D and Patent Box capability in-house covers that wider decision.

How the R&D Schemes Work

For accounting periods beginning on or after 1 April 2024, most UK companies claim under a single merged R&D expenditure credit scheme, which replaced the old split between the SME scheme and the Research and Development Expenditure Credit (RDEC) for larger companies. A separate, more generous regime — Enhanced R&D Intensive Support (ERIS) — applies to loss-making, R&D-intensive SMEs that meet a qualifying threshold. The Financial Controller’s first task on any claim is to establish which regime applies for the period in question, because the mechanics, the rates and the accounting treatment all differ.

The merged scheme operates as an above-the-line expenditure credit: the credit is taxable and is recognised in the accounts as income, which changes how the relief flows through the management and statutory accounts compared with the old SME enhanced deduction. The current rules, rates and definitions are set out in HMRC’s R&D relief guidance and the detailed page on the merged scheme and ERIS, which should be the reference point for any claim rather than a half-remembered version of the old rules.

Feature Merged scheme (RDEC) ERIS
Who Trading companies of any size, for periods beginning on or after 1 April 2024 Loss-making SMEs whose relevant R&D spend is at least 30% of total expenditure
Relief Taxable credit of 20% of qualifying expenditure Additional 86% deduction (186% in total), with losses surrenderable for a payable credit of up to 14.5%
Approximate net benefit 15% for a company paying tax at 25%; about 16.2% for loss-makers and small-profits-rate companies Up to about 27% of qualifying spend in cash for a loss-maker

The Merged Scheme in Detail

Under the merged scheme the credit is 20% of qualifying R&D expenditure and is itself taxable, so the net benefit depends on the company’s tax position. For a company paying the 25% main rate the net benefit is 15% of qualifying spend; loss-making companies apply a notional tax deduction at the 19% small profits rate, which gives a net benefit of about 16.2%. Because the credit sits above the line, the Financial Controller should model the net effect rather than quoting the headline 20% to the board as if it were the benefit.

Two further mechanics matter. Any payable amount is capped at £20,000 plus 300% of the company’s relevant PAYE and National Insurance liabilities, with the excess carried forward — worth checking early in a business with a small UK payroll. And for contracted-out R&D, broadly the company that decides to undertake the work and contracts it out now claims, rather than the subcontractor, which matters to any business performing R&D for customers.

Enhanced Support for R&D-Intensive SMEs

Loss-making SMEs whose relevant R&D expenditure is at least 30% of their total expenditure qualify for ERIS. HMRC’s guidance confirms the 30% intensity condition, measured including the expenditure of connected companies, and allows a company that met the condition in its previous 12-month period to claim for one further period if it falls below the threshold. ERIS gives an additional 86% deduction, and the resulting loss can be surrendered for a payable credit of up to 14.5% — worth up to roughly 27p per pound of qualifying spend.

For a Financial Controller at a loss-making, research-heavy business — typically early-stage technology or life sciences — whether the company meets the threshold is a material question. The intensity ratio and the treatment of connected companies warrant specialist input, but the Financial Controller should know when the question is live and model both outcomes in the cash forecast.

Periods Spanning the Transition

For accounting periods that straddle the introduction of the merged scheme, transitional rules determine which regime applies, and a claim for an earlier period must apply the rules in force at the time rather than the current ones. This is a practical trap: rates, qualifying cost categories and even the intensity threshold have changed over recent years (an earlier version of the R&D-intensive regime used a 40% test for periods beginning between 1 April 2023 and 31 March 2024). Establishing the correct period and the correct ruleset is the unglamorous first step that prevents a fundamentally misconceived claim.

Overseas Restrictions on Workers and Contracted R&D

For periods beginning on or after 1 April 2024, both the merged scheme and ERIS restrict relief for overseas activity. Externally provided workers broadly only qualify where they are paid through UK payroll and subject to UK National Insurance, and contracted-out R&D generally only qualifies where the work is done in the UK. Narrow exceptions apply where conditions needed for the R&D are not available in the UK — geography, environment, population or a legal or regulatory requirement — but cost or staff availability does not count. Northern Ireland companies claiming ERIS can be exempt. For a business with offshore development teams this can remove a large part of a previously qualifying claim, so map where each contractor actually does the work.

What Actually Qualifies as R&D

The single most common cause of a defective claim is a misunderstanding of what qualifies. The statutory definition, explained in the government’s guidelines on the meaning of R&D for tax purposes, is narrower than most people assume. Qualifying R&D requires a project that seeks an advance in science or technology through the resolution of scientific or technological uncertainty — uncertainty that a competent professional in the field could not readily resolve. This excludes a great deal of work that businesses informally describe as “development”.

The Financial Controller’s role is not to make the technical judgement — that belongs to the competent professionals on the projects — but to ensure that the judgement is genuinely made, properly documented and applied consistently. A claim that sweeps in routine development, cosmetic product changes or work that simply applies existing technology is exactly the kind that now attracts an enquiry. Insisting on a clear articulation of the uncertainty for each project, in the technical team’s own words, protects the company from that risk.

Identifying and Quantifying Qualifying Costs

Once the qualifying projects are established, the financial work begins, and this is where the Financial Controller’s contribution is most direct. Qualifying costs fall into defined categories: staffing costs for employees directly engaged in the R&D, a proportion of externally provided workers and subcontractors (subject to the overseas rules above), consumables including a proportion of power, water and materials consumed, software, and — for periods beginning on or after 1 April 2023 — certain data licence and cloud computing costs. Each category has its own rules and its own apportionment basis.

The largest cost in most claims is staff time, and quantifying it correctly means working from payroll data and a defensible apportionment of each relevant individual’s time on qualifying activity. A robust claim rests on a methodical apportionment, ideally supported by timesheets or contemporaneous records rather than a retrospective guess. Where time records do not exist, the apportionment must be reasonable, documented and consistent, and the Financial Controller should be able to explain how each percentage was reached.

A Worked Approach to Staff Apportionment

Consider a software business with twelve engineers, some of whom spend most of their time on genuinely uncertain technical work while others mainly deliver routine features and maintenance that do not qualify. The wrong approach is to claim a flat percentage of the whole team’s cost. The right approach is to work individual by individual: establish from project records and the team lead’s input what proportion of each engineer’s time over the period was spent on qualifying activity, document the basis, and apply it to that person’s total employment cost including employer’s National Insurance and pension. The result ties to the payroll, reflects who actually did qualifying work, and can be explained line by line if HMRC asks.

As an illustration only: if that build-up produces £400,000 of qualifying staff cost and £50,000 of qualifying cloud and software cost, the merged scheme credit is £90,000 (20% of £450,000). For a company paying tax at 25%, the net benefit is about £67,500. Presented to the board as “£90,000 of R&D credit” without that qualification, the number overstates the benefit by a third. That explicability is the whole point — a claim you can defend is worth more than a larger claim you cannot.

Preparing a Claim That Withstands Scrutiny

The current environment demands that every claim be prepared as if it will be enquired into. Since 8 August 2023 every claim must be supported by an additional information form submitted to HMRC before the company tax return that contains the claim; a claim without one is treated as invalid and removed from the return. The form sets out the projects, the qualifying expenditure by category, a technical narrative, and the names of the senior officer responsible and any agent involved. The Financial Controller should treat it not as a formality but as the company’s first line of defence — a clear, specific and honest account of why the projects qualify and how the costs were determined.

The hallmarks of a defensible claim are specificity and substantiation: a technical narrative that describes genuine uncertainty in concrete terms, a cost computation that ties to the ledgers and payroll, a documented and reasonable apportionment methodology, and a clear record of who made the qualifying technical judgements. Keeping that evidence in order as you go, rather than reconstructing it under enquiry pressure, is the single most valuable thing the Financial Controller can do for the company’s R&D position.

Claim Notification and Key Deadlines

Companies claiming for the first time, or that have not made a claim in the previous three years, must also submit a claim notification. Under HMRC’s claim notification rules, the window runs from the first day of the period of account to six months after its end, and a company that misses it cannot claim for that period at all. This catches out growing businesses whose first claim is prepared late by a new adviser, and companies that skipped a few years. The Financial Controller should diarise the date at the start of each period rather than discovering it when the claim is being prepared.

Step Deadline Who it applies to
Claim notification Within six months of the end of the period of account First-time claimants and those with no claim in the previous three years
Additional information form Before the company tax return containing the claim is filed Every claim
Claim in the CT600 Generally within two years of the end of the accounting period Every claim
Records retained At least six years from the end of the accounting period Every company

If HMRC Opens an Enquiry

HMRC’s compliance activity on R&D has risen markedly since the reforms began, with more claims checked before payment and more enquiries after filing, so treat an enquiry as a realistic possibility. If one is opened, the company’s position depends almost entirely on the evidence assembled at the time of the claim: a clear narrative, documented costs and contemporaneous records are defensible; a vague narrative and retrospective estimates are exposed. Respond to HMRC’s questions promptly and specifically, involve the people who made the technical judgements, and keep a record of every exchange. Where a claim is found to be wrong, the company can face repayment, interest and penalties, which is why the evidence-led approach is practical risk management rather than bureaucratic caution.

Need a Financial Controller who owns the R&D claim? — 0204 553 8893

We recruit permanent, interim and fractional Financial Controllers and in-house tax professionals who can run cost capture, documentation and the adviser relationship properly. We respond the same working day.

Tell us about your hire →Register as a candidate →

The Most Common Errors Financial Controllers Should Guard Against

The pattern of defective claims is well established. The first and most frequent is claiming for work that does not meet the uncertainty test — routine development, the application of existing technology, aesthetic or commercial improvements. The discipline that prevents this is insisting that each project’s uncertainty is articulated by a competent professional in concrete terms before any cost is attached to it.

The second is weak cost substantiation: unsupported apportionments, costs outside the qualifying categories, and contractor costs treated without regard to their rules, now including the overseas restrictions. The third is a generic additional information form that could describe any company — precisely the kind of submission that signals a weak claim. The fourth is applying the wrong scheme or rates to the period. The fifth, newer error is procedural: missing the claim notification window or filing the return before the additional information form, either of which can lose the relief entirely.

Record-Keeping and the Annual Cycle

The Financial Controller who manages R&D well builds the evidence through the year. Where qualifying projects are identifiable in advance, light-touch contemporaneous records — a note of the qualifying activity, who is working on it and roughly how much of their time — transform the quality of the eventual claim. This does not require an elaborate timesheet system; it requires a habit of capturing information close to when the work is done rather than reconstructing it months later under deadline pressure.

Building this into the finance calendar — a quarterly check-in with the technical teams, a maintained list of qualifying projects and the people working on them, project codes in the ledger for R&D-related spend, and an evidence folder that grows through the year — turns the annual claim from a scramble into an assembly of material already gathered. It fits naturally alongside the routines in our guide to optimising the month-end close.

Working With External Advisers

Most companies use an external adviser for their R&D claim, and a good adviser adds real value. The relationship to aim for is a collaborative one in which finance owns the cost substantiation and the company owns the technical judgement, with the adviser providing rules expertise and quality assurance — not one in which the claim is outsourced wholesale to a provider promising a large number for minimal input. The aggressive, contingent-fee providers that proliferated in recent years are precisely the ones whose claims have attracted scrutiny. Remember that the company, not the adviser, is responsible for the accuracy of the claim, and the additional information form names the adviser alongside the company’s senior officer. Managing this relationship well is part of the broader discipline of managing external tax advisers.

Choosing an R&D Adviser

When selecting or re-tendering an adviser, the Financial Controller should look for a firm that will challenge weak projects rather than maximise every claim, and whose team includes people regulated by a professional body such as the Chartered Institute of Taxation or the ICAEW. Useful questions include:

  • Who will actually prepare and review the claim, and what are their qualifications?
  • How is the fee calculated, and would a fixed or time-based fee be available instead of a percentage of the claim?
  • How will you test the technical narrative with our competent professionals?
  • What support will you provide, and at what cost, if HMRC opens an enquiry?
  • How many of your recent claims were checked or enquired into, and with what outcome?

R&D Relief in the Wider Financial Picture

An effective Financial Controller sees the R&D claim as one element of the company’s overall tax and cash position. Timing matters for cash flow planning: whether the benefit arrives as a reduction in a corporation tax liability or, for a loss-making company, as a payable credit after HMRC’s checks has direct consequences for the forecast. A company relying on the credit as a meaningful source of cash should reflect a realistic receipt date in its 13-week cash flow forecast, not assume it will arrive on a convenient date.

The claim also interacts with the company’s loss position, its broader tax planning and its group structure. In a group, the interaction between R&D claims, group relief, the allocation of qualifying activity across entities and the connected-company test for ERIS adds complexity that warrants careful handling, a theme covered in our guide for the Financial Controller in a multi-entity group. The claim also feeds into the annual return itself, covered in our guide to in-house corporation tax compliance.

The Accounting Treatment

The Financial Controller is responsible for the correct accounting treatment. Under the merged scheme the expenditure credit is generally accounted for in a similar way to a government grant and presented above the line, within operating results, while an ERIS payable credit is commonly presented within the tax line. Either way, the relief has implications for the deferred tax position and the effective tax rate, which our guide to deferred tax fundamentals explains. This is the point at which the claim stops being a tax exercise and becomes a financial reporting one, squarely within the controlling function’s accountability. Agree the presentation with the auditors before the year end and make sure the disclosure matches the claim filed.

What Good Looks Like

A Financial Controller managing the R&D claim well runs a process that is methodical, evidenced and defensible. Qualifying projects are identified by competent technical professionals with genuine uncertainty articulated; the claim notification is filed on time where needed; costs are built from payroll and ledgers with a documented apportionment; the additional information form is specific and honest; the accounting treatment is correct; and the supporting evidence is retained in an orderly way. Done this way, R&D relief is a recurring source of value claimed with confidence rather than anxiety.

Done badly — as an annual scramble handed to a contingent-fee provider with minimal finance input — it is a growing liability, which is why employers in technology and life sciences ask about this capability at interview. Our guide to hiring a Financial Controller for a technology business covers what else those employers look for.

The Financial Controller’s R&D Checklist

  • Confirm the regime for each period: merged scheme, ERIS or the pre-April 2024 rules.
  • Diarise the claim notification deadline at the start of every period if the company is a first-time or lapsed claimant.
  • Keep a live register of qualifying projects, the uncertainty each addresses and the people involved.
  • Build staff costs individual by individual from payroll, and map where every contractor works.
  • Check the PAYE cap and, for loss-makers, the ERIS intensity ratio including connected companies.
  • Review the additional information form before it is submitted and file it before the CT600.
  • Agree the accounting presentation with the auditors and model the net, not gross, benefit for the board.

Interim and Fractional Support for an R&D Claim

Not every business has a Financial Controller with the time or experience to run an R&D claim. An interim Financial Controller can own cost capture, the evidence pack and the adviser relationship for a defined period; typical day rates are £400–£650 in London, £350–£550 in the South East and £310–£490 in the Midlands and North, as set out in our guide to interim Financial Controller rates. Where the need is ongoing but part-time, a fractional Financial Controller working a day or two a week can build the year-round discipline described above.

For larger or more complex claims, an interim tax professional at typically £450–£700 a day can review the claim before filing or support an enquiry. Permanent Financial Controller salaries for comparison are in our Financial Controller salary guide. Interim and fractional shortlists can usually be provided within days, and permanent shortlists typically within one to two weeks.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which R&D scheme applies to my company?

For accounting periods beginning on or after 1 April 2024, most companies claim under the merged scheme at a 20% taxable credit. Loss-making SMEs whose relevant R&D spend is at least 30% of total expenditure can claim ERIS instead. Earlier periods use the rules in force at the time.

Do we need to notify HMRC before claiming?

If the company has not made an R&D claim in the previous three years, or is claiming for the first time, it must submit a claim notification within six months of the end of the period of account. Missing that window means no claim for the period. Every claim also needs an additional information form filed before the return.

What is the real value of the merged scheme credit?

The credit is 20% of qualifying expenditure but is taxable. For a company paying 25% corporation tax the net benefit is 15%; loss-makers apply a notional 19% rate, giving about 16.2%. Always quote the net figure to the board.

Can we claim for overseas contractors?

For periods beginning on or after 1 April 2024, contracted R&D and externally provided workers generally only qualify if the work is done in the UK or the workers are on UK payroll, with narrow exceptions where conditions for the R&D are not available in the UK. Cost alone is not an acceptable reason.

How long should we keep R&D records?

Keep the narrative, computations, time records and invoices for at least six years from the end of the accounting period, in line with HMRC’s general corporation tax record-keeping rules.

Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, Accountancy Capital

Fellow of the ICAEW | Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate | Part of FD Capital Group

Adrian is a former listed-company Finance Director who became an FD at 28 and holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London. He founded FD Capital in 2018 and then Accountancy Capital, where our recruitment team places Financial Controllers and tax professionals who treat R&D relief as part of the controlling function rather than an annual outsourced exercise.

View Adrian’s ICAEW profile

Related Pages and Resources

Tax in the Finance Function

The tax responsibilities that sit alongside the R&D claim.

→ In-house corporation tax compliance

→ Managing external tax advisers

→ R&D and Patent Box capability

Reporting and Close

Where R&D accounting meets the reporting cycle.

→ Deferred tax fundamentals

→ Optimising the month-end close

→ FC audit preparation

Hiring a Financial Controller

Permanent, interim and fractional Financial Controller hires.

→ Financial Controller recruitment

→ Fractional Financial Controller

→ Interim FC rates

Tax Hiring and Pay

Benchmarks for the in-house tax roles that support complex claims.

→ In-house Tax Manager salary guide

→ Interim tax day rates

→ Tax recruitment

Hiring a Financial Controller who adds value beyond the numbers? — 0204 553 8893

Accountancy Capital recruits qualified Financial Controllers across the UK on a permanent, interim and fractional basis, including candidates who own R&D claims, tax and reporting with real rigour. Fees are agreed in writing before a search starts. Email recruitment@accountancycapital.co.uk or call us.

Tell us about your hire →Register as a candidate →

Start a search

Tell us about your finance hire

Share a few details about the role and your timetable. A consultant will review your brief and come back to you the same working day.

  • Same-day response from a consultant who works on finance searches every day
  • Confidential from the first conversation, with no obligation to proceed
  • Permanent, interim and fractional finance roles across the UK
Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Your details are used only to respond to your enquiry.